Motion, Emotion, and Love:
The Nature of Artistic Performance
Thomas Carson Mark
My new book explores the artistic activity of performers. It is aimed at performers and their audiences, for whom it will have immediate practical value. Insight into the nature of artistic performance transforms a person's practicing, rehearsing, performing and teaching. It also transforms the experience of the audience. Audience members at concerts, the theatre, or dance performances will feel a new involvement with the performers and with what is happening onstage. Explaining how all this comes about requires some examination of theoretical topics such as: Are performers artists in their own right? What do they create? What is the relation of a work of performing art to a performance of that same work? These are philosophical questions, so to make good its practical purpose the book must also dip occasionally into philosophy.
I take motion as a point of departure, because everything performers do is done by moving their bodies. Intentional bodily movement depends on a body map that governs it, and understanding the relation of movement to the body map is a source of power in practicing and performing. But performing is not mere movement, it also communicates emotion, so the book must explain how motion is used to convey emotion and how audience members comprehend and respond to emotion thus conveyed.
The concept of love is the third essential topic. Love does not refer to anything that performers directly do, but rather to the preconditions that must be met if performance is to be successful. Love enters the picture in several ways. The performer must be secure in himself, which can be seen as a form of self-love. In addition, the relation of performers to one another in performance has the earmarks of a loving relationship and so does the interaction of performer and audience. When performer and audience feel themselves in such a relationship the occasion becomes memorably significant and powerful.
Seeing performance in terms of motion, emotion, and love, and also making clear what it is that performers create, reveals that performance yields artworks different from anything available in non-performing art. A performance offers an experience with greater intensity and a more coherent structure than the ordinary experiences of life; in performance, one's experience during that stretch of time is shaped into an artwork.
Motion, Emotion, and Love is decorated with a series of 17th-century etchings titled Balli di Sfessania by Jacques Callot (1592-1635).
These etchings are usually described as depicting characters from the commedia dell' arte, a form of improvisatory comedy that began in Italy before 1550 and was popular throughout Europe by 1600. Productions combined rehearsed scenes with improvised dialogue, along with song and dance, and acrobatics. There was a lot of humor, much of it bawdy. Plots followed a few standard story lines (young lovers aided by a pert serving girl in overcoming the resistance of a miserly, tyrannical parent or guardian, for example) and used a number of stock characters (the blustering captain, the pedantic doctor, the clown, the comic servant). Many characters wore masks, and the male costumes often included a prominent phallus, in keeping with the bawdy humor and depicted in some of the Callot etchings.
The word sfessania in the title of Callot's etchings has mystified many commentators, and some scholars now doubt whether the Balli etchings actually depict commedia dell' arte figures. It appears that by the fifteenth century a dance called the moresca, which could include furious gestures, wild poses, and mock battles, was popular throughout Europe. In Naples, at the turn of the 17th century, a form of moresca was known as the sfessania. Callot is not known to have visited Naples, but he spent some years in Florence and his images fit the descriptions we have of this dance, so it is plausible that it, not the commedia dell' arte, is the principal subject of the Balli series of etchings. For illustrative purposes in my new book, nothing hinges on settling that question. Whatever their historical subject, the etchings are marvelously gestural, full of movement and energy; perfect accompaniments to a book on motion, emotion, and love in artistic performance.
Motion, Emotion, and Love: The Nature of Artistic Performance was published in October, 2012, by GIA Publications, Inc. It is available from the publisher, or from
Powell's Books in Portland OR, or from Amazon:
pianomap home page
Published editorial reviews
"Performing artists . . . have a goldmine of information in Thomas Carson Mark's
latest book. . . . a fascinating work of enormous significance. . . . If
everyone who attends live performances were to read this book, performers and
audiences would benefit tremendously.
"What gives this book such importance, I think, is the science and philosphy that governs it. . . . That said, the book is an extremely easy read, and frankly,
impossible to put
down. It is a very handsome book, beautifully written and obviously written with a great deal of love. This reviewer has now read the book from cover to cover
--American Music Teacher, April/May 2013
Reader's comments on Motion, Emotion, and Love
"Your writing is so clear and accessible and your examples so instructive, that I came away much enlightened. I appreciated your grounding performance (and its reception) in the physical body, explaining its simultaneous creation and existence in the moment, and demystifying vague but widely embraced concepts such as artistic inspiration. Performing artists of all stripes will undoubtedly love this book, but I can assure you that amateurs like me will also find it fascinating. From now on, thanks to you, my behavior as an audience member will be more considerate and my experience of musical and theatrical performances will be immensely enriched."
Sue Taylor, Professor of Art History,
Portland State University
"I have read your book and have been fascinated by it. What a labour of love! A wonderful subject that as far as I know has rarely been treated in this depth. I applaud your use of comparative anecdote/example and I love the triplet Emotion, Motion, and Love. Your viewpoint is refreshingly forthright!"
Paul Roberts, Department of Keyboard Studies,
The Guildhall School, London
"I've quite enjoyed reading your manuscript, with its strong authorial voice, careful unfolding of a powerful argument, and inspiring conclusions. In places, particularly at the ends of sections and the end of the book, your voice is eloquent and poetic without sacrificing accuracy or clarity. The momentum of the logic is elegant and serves the argument--the book--well."
Laura Helper-Ferris, editor,
Helper-Ferris Editorial Agency, Memphis
"Such a powerful work. This book made me think a lot, made me feel vindicated in some ways . . . made me laugh out loud. You have such a way with words with a perfect dose of down-to-earth humanness thrown in. I can appreciate the vulnerability and courage it has taken to put this out to the world, not unlike performing. And by the end, there were tears in my eyes."
Bridget Jankowski, Pianist and teacher, Cuyahoga Falls, Ohio
Pianomap is created, written, and maintained by pianist/teacher
Thomas Mark. If you have comments or
suggestions about this website, please send him an email.